Skip to content
Give
← News
Celebrity & Music Faith Stories August 20, 2026

How God Redeemed This Actress’ Story After Spiritual Manipulation

Bethany Joy Lenz
BEVERLY HILLS, CALIFORNIA - MAY 20: Bethany Joy Lenz attends The Alliance For Women In Media Foundation's 50th Annual Gracie Awards Gala at Beverly Wilshire, A Four Seasons Hotel on May 20, 2025 in Beverly Hills, California. (Photo by Frazer Harrison/Getty Images)

After a decade of spiritual manipulation, ONE TREE HILL actress and author Bethany Joy Lenz had to learn God’s voice all over again.

“God is in control, and the story is not done,” she said on Annie F. Downs’ “That Sounds Fun” podcast.

Downs asked a hard, honest question: How do you trust God when people close to you have repeatedly used His name to control you?

Lenz did not pretend she found the answer overnight. She began by allowing herself to make mistakes and refusing to spend the rest of her life terrified that one wrong step would make her a bad Christian.

“I’m going to live my life. I’m going to move with my instincts the way I want to. I’m going to live in the open mess, and you [God] come find me,” Lenz said in the full conversation.

“If I’m in the middle of something and you speak up in my spirit and I feel like you’re saying, ‘This is not the right move,’ I won’t do it,” she continued.

Related: Actress Bethany Joy Lenz Reveals How Childhood Faith Impacted Her Life

There is a beautiful trust in that answer. Lenz stopped expecting the Lord to hide traps in her path and trusted Him to speak clearly enough for her to obey.

“I couldn’t walk away from God,” she said.

Lenz explained that a profound encounter with God at 19 gave her something solid to return to after she left the group. She questioned religious systems, studied other beliefs and kept searching, but the Gospel kept pulling her back to Jesus.

“The thing that made the most existential sense was the Christ story,” she said. “I didn’t have to do the work. God came and did the work for me.”

Lenz recounts the manipulation, financial exploitation and long road home in her memoir, Dinner for Vampires: Life on a Cult TV Show (While Also in an Actual Cult!). Becoming a mother helped her see what she could no longer accept.

“I refused to allow [my daughter] to experience this, and that’s when I got out, got into therapy, and my whole relationship with the Lord completely shifted at that point,” Lenz said on the “Jesus Calling” podcast.

As Movieguide® previously reported, Lenz credits the late pastor and author Tim Keller with helping her rebuild her faith through reason and logic. Asking difficult questions did not drive her farther from Christ.

“The more that I thought, the more solid my faith has become, and [I’m] excited for what the adventure is that’s around the corner,” she said.

That distinction matters for anyone who has watched a person twist Scripture into a leash. A cruel or controlling leader may misuse God’s name, but that leader does not get to define God’s character.

Christ is still the One who comes looking. Grace still meets us in the mess, even when healing moves slower than we wish.

“God is big enough to not be intimidated or afraid of your questions, your mess, that spaghetti bowl of confusion,” Lenz said. “God is big enough to untangle it and to speak to you in the midst of it and to guide you. As long as you are open to that, don’t be afraid.”

Read Next: Bethany Joy Lenz’s Memoir to Recount Escape from Cult: ‘Story of Forgiveness’

Questions or comments? Please write to us here.

Related Stories

More News →