Skip to content
Give
← All TV Reviews
WHERE TO WATCH
TV REVIEW

LOVE FINDS YOU IN CHARM

An Amish Jane Austen story with a slow start and a warm, faithful heart.

2015TBDUP TVDrama
Worth the trip.
PRODUCTION QUALITY ★★★★ 3 / 4 Lovely to look at, slow to start, terrific by the end.
FAMILY CONTENT Family +4 on the +4 to −4 scale A strongly Christian, moral story safe and worthwhile for the whole family.
CONTENT LEVELS NONE → HEAVY
Language None
Violence None
Sex None
Nudity None
BEST FOR Families who enjoy gentle romance, Jane Austen fans, and anyone who loves Amish fiction.
NOT FOR Viewers hoping for the mystery and momentum of the earlier Love Finds You film set in Sugarcreek.
CONTENT IN ONE LINE Nothing beyond a brief shirtless farm scene and a villain who drinks two glasses of wine — a genuinely wholesome watch.
SHARE f 𝕏 ✉ ⧉

Should You Watch It?

This is a movie you can hand to the whole family without a second thought. It's beautifully shot — idyllic Amish farmland, warm light, unhurried pace — and it borrows Jane Austen's old trick of pitting sense against sensibility in a young woman's heart. The Christian faith isn't decoration here; it's the engine of the story, right down to the father's challenge to his daughter to test her convictions for herself.

The one honest complaint: patience is required. The story's real conflict — a wealthy, worldly suitor pursuing an Amish girl who's already drawn to a good man closer to home — doesn't arrive until nearly halfway through. Once it does, the movie finally takes off, and the ending pays off everything that came before.

If you love a slow, pastoral romance with a moral spine and don't mind a sluggish first half, this is a satisfying watch for movie night with your family.

The Story

NO SPOILERS — WE KEEP THE SURPRISES

Emma is an Amish girl with a secret: she reads Jane Austen by lamplight in the barn and dreams of a wider world. When her father discovers her hidden books, he doesn't punish her — he sends her away, to test her faith for herself at her cousin's farm in Charm, Ohio. There, grief has left the household shorthanded, a steady young Amish man named Noah has stepped in to help, and a sophisticated outsider is about to arrive with very different intentions. Which path Emma chooses is the story worth watching unfold.

Is It Any Good?

Three stars means this is a genuinely good, well-crafted television film with one real flaw. The direction and cinematography are strong — the pastoral scenery is gorgeous, and the Austen-inspired "sense versus sensibility" framework gives the romance real shape rather than letting it drift.

The flaw is structural: the antagonist doesn't show up until roughly 40 percent into the runtime, and the film has little forward momentum until he does. Patient viewers are rewarded, though — the source calls the ending "terrific," and the back-half tension between the two suitors gives the story the pull it was missing earlier. It doesn't match the mystery-driven energy of its predecessor, Love Finds You in Sugarcreek, but on its own terms it succeeds.

The Worldview

This is a film that wants you to take faith seriously — not as a backdrop, but as a live question. Emma's father doesn't shield her from doubt; he sends her out to wrestle with it honestly, trusting that a tested faith is a real one. That's a mature, biblical instinct, echoing Paul's charge to "test everything; hold fast what is good" (1 Thessalonians 5:21). The story overtly names God, prayer, redemption, and forgiveness, and its moral architecture is unmistakably Christian: faithfulness to home, community, and a humble suitor is set against the seduction of wealth, flattery, and a stranger's lust dressed up as sophistication.

The villain is drawn almost too plainly — described as looking "slightly devilish" — which keeps the moral stakes clear for younger viewers, even if it costs the story some nuance. What the film exalts, though, is worth celebrating: a young woman choosing enduring love and rooted faith over glamour and self-interest.

Underneath the romance is a homesickness every viewer will recognize — the pull toward home, plain living, and people who actually know you. Scripture speaks straight into that longing: "But now they desire a better country, that is, a heavenly one" (Hebrews 11:16). Emma's Ohio farmhouse is a good picture of a much better home still to come.

Movieguide® worldview codes: CCC, BBB, A, M — preserved for our database, awards research and the annual Report to the Entertainment Industry. What the codes mean →

The Content Guide

The specifics — spoilers included by nature — so you can judge for your own family.

Content Summary

Very strong Christian, moral worldview with overt references to God, faith, prayer, redemption, and forgiveness; no foul language; no violence; no sex, but several kisses; man chopping wood has his shirt rise up, and there’s partial upper male nudity; villain drinks two glasses of wine; no smoking or drugs; and, girl wrestles with leaving her Amish Christian faith.

Talk About It

Four questions for the couch, the commute, or the couple bingeing it together.

01

Emma's father sends her away to test her faith rather than forbidding her doubts. Why might that be wiser than simply shielding her from temptation?

1 Thessalonians 5:21 · Proverbs 22:6
02

Andy offers Emma glamour and attention; Noah offers steady, humble love. What does Scripture say about the difference between what dazzles and what actually lasts?

1 Peter 3:3–4 · Proverbs 31:30
03

Emma has to leave home to figure out what she actually believes. Has anything like that ever happened in your own faith journey?

04

The story ends with Emma discovering "there's no place like home." How does that longing point toward the eternal home Scripture promises believers?

Hebrews 11:16 · John 14:2–3

The Final Word

This is a sweet, well-made, deeply moral little romance that earns its patience-testing first half with a genuinely satisfying second. It's safe for every age in your household and worth the wait for its terrific ending. Our answer: worth the trip.

THE VERDICT Worth the trip.
WHERE TO WATCH

More TV Shows Like This

Browse All Reviews →