Skip to content
Give
← All Book Reviews
Standalone novel Novel
BOOK REVIEW

WISH (AI DRAFT)

A lonely girl finds a home, a friend and a dog.

Barbara O’ConnorFarrar, Straus and Giroux240 pagesAges 9–12Middle-grade contemporary fiction
Read it together.
WRITING QUALITY ★★★★ 4 / 4 Excellent first-person voice and warmly drawn characters.
FAMILY CONTENT Family +1 on the +4 to −4 scale Family-friendly, with brief fights, angry words and superstitious wishing.
CONTENT LEVELS NONE → HEAVY
Language Light
Violence Light
Sex None
Substances None
BEST FOR Middle-grade readers ready to talk about anger, family struggles and faith.
NOT FOR Children unsettled by neglectful parents, foster care or peer bullying.
IN ONE LINE A tender story of belonging and Christian community, with wish-making rituals and a hot-tempered heroine.
READING LEVEL Middle-grade prose with short chapters and a conversational first-person voice.
WHERE TO GET IT Hardcover paperback e-book and audiobook Your library
SHARE f 𝕏 ✉ ⧉

The Worldview

Read it together if your child is ready to discuss angry reactions, a troubled home life and the difference between wishing and praying. Charlie is a lonely girl whose steady aunt and uncle, loyal friend and Christian community show her patient care.

The novel honors kindness, forgiveness, faithful friendship and a loving home. Howard’s family prays at meals, and church, Sunday school and Vacation Bible School are part of the town’s life. Charlie’s father dismisses churchgoers as “do-gooders and Bible-thumpers,” but the story does not share his contempt. At the same time, Charlie repeatedly relies on folk rituals—wishing on stars and other things—as a way to hope. The story does not identify those wishes with prayer or explain hope as trust in God. That contrast offers a natural opening for you to talk about bringing our needs to God. The book’s central longing is for a secure home: “God settles the solitary in a home” (Psalm 68:6).

Movieguide® worldview codes: BB, CC, L, V, M — preserved for our database, awards research and the annual Report to the Entertainment Industry. What the codes mean →

The Story

NO SPOILERS — WE KEEP THE SURPRISES

Eleven-year-old Charlie Reese is sent from Raleigh to live with relatives she barely knows in a small Blue Ridge Mountain town. She wants to go home, but her kind aunt and uncle, a persistent new friend named Howard and a stray dog begin to change what home means to her.

The Content Guide

The specifics — spoilers included by nature — so you can judge for your own reader.

Language Light
Violence Light
Sex None
Substances None
The filled dot marks the level Movieguide® found in this book. For prose we report Substances in place of Nudity. Written detail for every category is below. How we measure content →
WHERE THE HARD PARTS ARE
  • Chapter One Charlie describes her father being in jail for fighting and her mother staying in bed while she is sent to live with relatives.
  • School scene Charlie kicks a classmate.
  • Vacation Bible School scene Charlie exchanges shoves with a boy who mocks Howard; a teacher intervenes.
  • Bertha’s recollection Charlie’s mother bites another child’s hand.

A locator so a parent can pre-read the scenes that matter instead of the whole book.

Dominant Worldview and Other Worldview Content/Elements

Strong moral and Christian elements honor kindness, forgiveness, family care and church fellowship. Charlie believes lucky signs and repeated wish-making rituals can help her wish come true; these practices are distinct from the prayer shown elsewhere in the story. Charlie recalls her father disparaging churchgoers, although the caring Christian families are portrayed positively.

Foul Language

No obscenities or profanities. Mild words including “heck” and “dang” appear several times. Insults include “hillbilly” and “loser”; a character’s mother is said to have shouted cuss words, but the words are not given.

Violence

Light, non-graphic fighting, such as Charlie kicking a classmate at school and exchanging shoves with a boy who mocks Howard at Vacation Bible School. A recollection describes Charlie’s mother biting another child’s hand. No blood or deaths.

Sex

No sex. Charlie notices her aunt and uncle holding hands.

Nudity

No nudity.

Alcohol Use

No alcohol use.

Smoking and/or Drug Use and Abuse

No drug use.

Miscellaneous Immorality

Charlie is rude, tells hurtful lies and insults others, and responds to teasing with physical aggression. Other children mock Howard for his limp. The story treats bullying and Charlie’s behavior as wrong; her aunt encourages her to make things right, and Charlie feels regret. Charlie’s parents are neglectful, and her father is repeatedly jailed for fighting; their conduct is not held up as a model.

Is the Writing Any Good?

Four stars: the first-person voice is lively and believable, and the mountain-town setting and supporting characters feel warmly specific. Charlie’s temper gives the story friction, while the short chapters and clear prose suit middle-grade readers. The gentle humor keeps a difficult family situation readable without pretending it is easy.

Talk About It

Four questions for the dinner table, the car, or a parent and teen reading it together.

01

Charlie makes wishes on stars and other things when she feels lonely. What do you turn to when you are worried, and how is praying different from wishing on an object?

Philippians 4:6–7 · Psalm 62:8
02

Howard keeps befriending Charlie even when she pushes him away. What does faithful friendship look like when someone is having a hard time?

Proverbs 17:17 · John 15:12
03

Charlie sometimes answers teasing with anger or a shove. What could she do instead, and how can you stand up for someone who is being mocked?

James 1:19–20 · Ephesians 4:32
04

Bertha and Gus welcome Charlie even when she is rude. What makes a home feel safe and loving, and how can your family offer that care to someone else?

Psalm 68:6 · Romans 12:10

The Final Word

WISH has real warmth: its patient relatives, steady friendship and church community offer a hopeful picture of care. Charlie’s repeated wish-making rituals and her fights are good reasons to talk as you read. Our answer: Read it together.

THE VERDICT Read it together.

More Books Like This

Browse All Reviews →