WHAT IF. . .?: Episode 1.1-2 “What If. . . Captain Carter Were the First Avenger?” and “What If. . . T’Challa Became a Star-Lord?”
Terrific, morally uplifting episodes with discernment needed for older children.
Should You Watch It?
These first two episodes are terrifically entertaining, redemptive stories about heroes overcoming evil. They promote courage, perseverance, sacrifice, humility, friendship, liberty, and family responsibility.
The action violence is strong, especially in the first episode. There is also brief foul language, drinking, light innuendo about a scientist being a playboy, feminist undertones, and a multiverse concept the source identifies as false humanism. Those concerns call for parental discernment, not a rejection of the episodes’ moral strengths.
You can watch if your older children are ready for strong superhero action and you are prepared to discuss the worldview issues.
The Story
NO SPOILERS — WE KEEP THE SURPRISESA mysterious being called The Watcher introduces a multiverse where one decision can create an entirely different reality.
In one episode, Peggy Carter becomes the Allies’ first super soldier after Steve Rogers is injured. In the other, Wakanda’s Prince T’Challa is kidnapped by space pirates and grows into a very different kind of Star-Lord. Both stories place familiar Marvel characters in new circumstances.
Is It Any Good?
Four stars means these episodes are exceptionally entertaining. The animation, familiar Marvel characters, alternate realities, action, and frequent cameos create a lively superhero experience.
The stories also have strong moral centers. Peggy’s courage and perseverance help her become an effective hero. T’Challa’s conscience and sense of family obligation lead him toward important discoveries about friendship, liberty, and home.
The Worldview
The series imagines a multiverse in which different decisions create different Marvel superheroes and alternate outcomes. The Watcher appears to observe these realities from a transcendent vantage point, while the most benevolent and heroic characters pursue virtues that align with biblical morality, including sacrifice, humility, and opposition to evil.
The first episode includes strong patriotic and anti-fascist sentiments, along with feminist undertones that villainize military figures who reject women as soldiers. Some Nazis seek deification through powers connected to pagan legend. The series also relies on the humanist concept of a multiverse, which the source describes as deceptive and not factually or scientifically proven. A multiverse would still require a transcendent cause: an eternal, unchangeable, nonmaterial, benevolent, personal, and just yet merciful Creator.
The second episode tells a Prodigal Son story as T’Challa returns toward his royal family. Scripture gives that longing a deeper homecoming: “And he arose and came to his father” (Luke 15:20).
The Content Guide
The specifics — spoilers included by nature — so you can judge for your own family.
Dominant Worldview and Other Worldview Content/Elements
A hierarchy of physical beings are exhibited throughout the series, though one character named The Watcher seems like a character with some sort of transcendent vantage point, the most benevolent and heroic characters live up to a moral code that strives for virtues aligning with Christian, biblical morality promoting sacrifice, fighting evil, humility, etc. (Episode 1.2 tells a Prodigal Son story), with strong patriotic, anti-fascist sentiments, plus some feminist undertones persist in Episode 1.1 (including villainizing military figures who don’t believe women should be soldiers), some Nazis have joined a secret organization intent on world domination and discuss ascending to a level of deification and obtaining this involves consulting powers beyond themselves that are steeped in pagan legend, and the series relies on the false humanist concept of a multiverse, which is deceptive and has never been factually or scientifically proven
Foul Language
A few light obscenities in each episode such as “bloody hell” and “no way in hell”
Violence
Lots of strong action violence such as wrestling, choking, kicking, hitting, acts of terrorism, heavy artillery fire, explosions where people are killed, people mortally shot or wounded by gunfire, tanks blown up, a man crushed to death by a creature’s tentacles, and discussions about murder, genocide and death
Sex
A character briefly and metaphorically comments on the romantic escapades of a “playboy”
Nudity
No nudity
Alcohol Use
Several scenes of characters drinking together in a bar, a talking alien duck remarks how he needs a drink, and a woman talks about the lack of effects alcohol has on her system
Smoking and/or Drug Use and Abuse
No references to smoking or drugs;
Miscellaneous Immorality
A child is kidnapped by space pirates and woman alludes to a scientist’s ability to “push buttons.”
Talk About It
Questions for the drive home, the dinner table, or the youth group.
Peggy Carter faces opposition because she is a woman soldier. How can courage and perseverance help us follow what is right when others reject us?
Joshua 1:9 · Galatians 6:9T’Challa learns the importance of friendship, liberty, and family. What responsibilities do we have toward our families and neighbors?
Mark 12:31 · 1 Timothy 5:8The second episode presents a return to a father as a joyful homecoming. What does Jesus’ parable of the Prodigal Son teach about repentance and welcome?
Luke 15:11–24The series imagines many alternate realities. Why does the Christian belief in a Creator matter when we think about the origin and order of the universe?
Genesis 1:1 · Acts 17:24–25The Final Word
These episodes pair excellent entertainment with heroic virtues, redemptive stories, and meaningful family themes. Strong action violence and several worldview concerns mean younger viewers need discernment. For older children and adults, WORTH WATCHING — OLDER CHILDREN AND ADULTS.