THANKSGIVING (2023)
A slick, gory holiday slasher with nothing at its center.
Should You Watch It?
Here is the decision, plainly. THANKSGIVING is a holiday slasher — a masked killer picking off the townspeople of Plymouth, Massachusetts, one themed murder at a time. Director Eli Roth is skilled, and there's a certain dark creativity to his irreverence, which is why the craft rates as high as it does.
But craft is not conscience. This is a gore-fest, and the source calls it exactly that: a distasteful, immoral take on the holiday that revels in the killer's lust for blood. The violence is relentless and explicit. The language runs past 130 "f" words. There are implied teen encounters, drunk teenagers, and underage substance abuse. And there is no moral worldview underneath it to make any of the ugliness mean something.
So the answer is simple. This one exists to entertain with torture, and it's best left untouched. Skip it.
The Story
NO SPOILERS — WE KEEP THE SURPRISESIn Plymouth, Massachusetts, a Right Mart department store opens early on Thanksgiving evening for a Black Friday sale. The owner's daughter, Jess, stops by before heading to the movies with friends — and the mob outside turns deadly, leaving several people dead.
One year later, a killer dressed as the pilgrim John Carver seems bent on revenge against everyone tied to that massacre. Jess and her friends can only watch as the killings begin. That's where we'll leave you.
Is It Any Good?
Three stars, and here's what they mean — and don't. On the level of pure filmmaking, Roth knows what he's doing. The source credits him with an attempt at genuine creativity in his irreverence, staging a holiday-themed slasher with confidence and a nasty streak of wit. For fans of the genre, the technical execution is there.
But the source is blunt that the whole is a gore-fest — a movie more concerned with the spectacle of making Thanksgiving a gory mess than with anything else. The stars measure the polish of the machine, not the worth of what it produces. This is a well-oiled gore delivery system with nothing to say. Skilled hands, empty heart.
The Worldview
The source finds only the faintest flicker of anything good here. People occasionally try to help one another escape the killer, and a father and daughter repair their relationship. Those are real moral notes — but the source says they're marred, and finally buried, by the movie's apparent enjoyment in showing off the killer's lust for blood.
Beyond that, there is no moral compass. The source is emphatic: the film lacks any real moral worldview and exists purely to entertain audiences with gore, torture, and extreme violence. Where a story might use fear to say something true about evil, justice, or the fragility of life, this one simply piles up bodies for the spectacle.
That's the deepest problem. Scripture does not deny that the world is full of violence — it names it plainly and grieves it. But it never invites us to delight in bloodshed. "Whatever is true, whatever is honorable... whatever is lovely... think about these things" (Philippians 4:8). A film that revels in dismemberment as entertainment asks the opposite of us. There is real thanksgiving to be had this season — but not here.
The Content Guide
The specifics — spoilers included by nature — so you can judge for your own family.
Dominant Worldview and Other Worldview Content/Elements
Light moral elements as people try to help one another escape killer, and father and daughter repair their relations, but marred by the movie’s apparent enjoyment for showing explicitly the killer’s lust for blood during the Thanksgiving holiday
Foul Language
Strong foul language throughout, with more than 130 “f” words, 12 “s” word, as well as other obscenities, plus more than 20 profanities involving God’s and Jesus’ names and several crude hand gestures
Violence
Slasher violence throughout with blood, vomit and gore, including severed heads and dismembered corpses, a woman is baked alive and served like a turkey, the murderer carves her like a turkey and tries to feed it to another victim, people are diced, chopped and sliced in half, a person’s intestines are seen in one scene, faces are smashed with a mallet, many stabbings with various weapons, scalpings, broken bones, a women must peel off her own skin to escape a freezer, and more, mention of giving guns to high schoolers, mention of pedophiles and rapists
Sex
Implied fornication and an implied illicit affair, plus references to pedophiles and rapists
Nudity
No graphic nudity, upper male nudity as a boy shows off his abs, a woman is stripped naked and burned alive (only her back legs and back can be seen), and a teenage girl wears revealing underwear during an implied sex scene
Alcohol Use
Teenagers are drunk at a party
Smoking and/or Drug Use and Abuse
Several teenagers mention taking Adderall to get better grades;
Miscellaneous Immorality
The whole movie lacks a moral compass and purely exists to entertain audiences with gore, torture and other extreme examples of violence.
Talk About It
Questions for the drive home, the dinner table, or the youth group.
This movie treats horrific violence as entertainment. Why does Scripture warn us against delighting in what we watch and think about, and how do we guard what we take in?
Philippians 4:8 · Psalm 101:3The story is built around revenge for a past wrong. What does the Bible say belongs to God rather than to us when we've been hurt?
Romans 12:19 · Deuteronomy 32:35The one bright spot the reviewer noticed was a father and daughter repairing their relationship. Why does even a dark story reach for reconciliation, and what does true restoration between people look like?
Ephesians 4:32 · Luke 15:20Thanksgiving is meant to be a season of gratitude. What does it look like to reclaim that with a genuinely thankful heart?
1 Thessalonians 5:18 · Psalm 100The Final Word
Eli Roth can make a movie — that much is true, and it's why the craft rates as high as it does. But skill in the service of a bloody, empty spectacle isn't a reason to watch. This one has no moral center and revels in the gore, so our answer is the plain one: skip it. Looking for something to enjoy with the family this season instead? Start with our latest family-friendly picks.