Shoplifting used to mean sneaking a shirt out of a store under a baggy coat. Now a teen can pull off the same theft from the couch, with a phone, a saved credit card and a made-up complaint to customer service.
It’s called digital shoplifting, and according to Parents, it’s common enough now that parents need to get ahead of it before the habit takes root.
“[Digital shoplifting] can lead to a desensitization to unethical behavior, and if they are able to get away with it, they may feel emboldened to try other forms of dishonesty in other aspects of their life,” said Dr. Pamela Walters, MD, medical director and consultant psychiatrist at Eulas Clinics.
The scheme takes a few different forms, but they all boil down to the same lie. A teen might claim an order never arrived, report a delivered item as damaged or wear an outfit once and return it anyway for a full refund. Others send back a cheaper item in place of what they’re supposed to return, pocketing money on merchandise nobody actually gave up.
It’s a theft with no cashier to dodge and no alarm to trip — which is exactly what makes it feel harmless to a kid who’d never dream of walking out of a store with a shirt under their coat. Retailers feel the cost anyway. The National Retail Federation estimated that 9% of the nearly $850 billion in merchandise Americans return every year is fraudulent, a bill that gets passed back to shoppers through higher prices and stricter return policies.
Related: How TikTok Influences Teens’ Shopping Decisions
Dr. Walters told Parents that the fix starts with a real conversation, not a lecture.
“Instead of simply telling teens, ‘That’s wrong, don’t do it,’ try explaining why it’s unethical,” she said. “If they believe they’re only hurting a big company, explain that — even indirectly — digital shoplifting can have impacts across an organization, contributing to things like price hikes, stricter return policies and even job losses for customer service workers,” she said.
That’s a conversation Scripture settled a long time ago — Exodus 20:15 doesn’t leave room for a loophole between a shoplifted sweater and a lied-about delivery. Movieguide® has long made the case that raising discerning kids starts with teaching them the difference between what they want and what they’re actually owed, well before anyone hands them a credit card.
Dr. Walters added that parents carry more weight here than they might realize, since kids notice how the adults around them handle their own gray areas. “If parents or peers are engaging in ‘harmless’ fraud, such as exaggerating complaints for discounts, kids will perceive these behaviors as acceptable,” she said. “Remove this risk by leading by example.”
Consequences matter too. Parents recommends that parents who catch a teen digital shoplifting require them to repay the cost of the item or lose online purchasing privileges — treating it with the same seriousness as theft from a store, because that’s exactly what it is.
None of this means writing off e-commerce or handing teens a permanent ban on Amazon. It means talking early, keeping an eye on the family’s own online habits, and treating honesty on a screen the same way Christian families have always treated it off one.
Read Next: How TikTok Drives Gen Z Women Into Debt
Questions or comments? Please write to us here.
