Skip to content
Give
← All Book Reviews
Dog Man, volume 1 Graphic novel
BOOK REVIEW

DOG MAN (AI DRAFT)

A loyal canine cop brings laughs, crime-fighting and bathroom humor.

Dav PilkeyGraphix, an imprint of Scholastic240 pagesAges 7+ publisher recommendationGraphic novel; humor and adventure
Read it together.
WRITING QUALITY ★★★★ 3 / 4 Energetic art and comic invention, with deliberately rough storytelling.
FAMILY CONTENT Family +1 on the +4 to −4 scale +1, Family. Family-friendly, but frequent potty humor and a mocking joke about a teacher merit a parent's guidance.
CONTENT LEVELS NONE → HEAVY
Language Light
Violence Light
Sex None
Substances None
BEST FOR Elementary readers who enjoy goofy graphic novels and families willing to discuss the humor.
NOT FOR Young children who copy crude jokes or need authority figures treated respectfully.
IN ONE LINE A funny, loyal hero and bright cartoon action share pages with repeated bathroom jokes and insults.
READING LEVEL Short, illustrated sections and intentional misspellings make it accessible; crude humor is the more important consideration.
WHERE TO GET IT Hardcover ebook Your library
SHARE f 𝕏 ✉ ⧉

The Worldview

Read it together if your child enjoys silly comics; the loyal hero and playful action come with enough crude humor and disrespectful jokes to call for your guidance.

DOG MAN celebrates persistence, quick thinking and a dog's stubborn affection for his boss. Dog Man keeps helping the police chief even when the chief scolds him, and the villains' plans are stopped. Those choices give the story a welcome thread of loyalty and courage. It does not offer a Christian understanding of right and wrong or name God. It also treats unruly behavior as a running joke: Dog Man ignores house-training rules, and a teacher's letter introducing ‘Book ’Em, Dog Man’ turns a teacher's complaint into a punchline. You can enjoy the story's affection and imagination while reminding your child that funny does not always mean wise or kind.

The book's appeal is its silly freedom and its hero's steady loyalty. Scripture gives us a better guide for what our words should do: “Let no corrupting talk come out of your mouths, but only such as is good for building up, as fits the occasion, that it may give grace to those who hear” (Ephesians 4:29).

*Movieguide® worldview codes: B, L, V, M*

Movieguide® worldview codes: B, L, V, M — preserved for our database, awards research and the annual Report to the Entertainment Industry. What the codes mean →

The Story

NO SPOILERS — WE KEEP THE SURPRISES

George and Harold bring back a comic-book hero they invented: Dog Man, a crime-fighting cop with a dog's head and a human body. He has a nose for trouble and a hard time resisting dog habits, while Petey the cat dreams up schemes that put the city in danger. The book races through four short, silly adventures, with bright illustrations, imaginative inventions and jokes that may make a parent reach for the pre-read.

The Content Guide

The specifics — spoilers included by nature — so you can judge for your own reader.

Language Light
Violence Light
Sex None
Substances None
The filled dot marks the level Movieguide® found in this book. For prose we report Substances in place of Nudity. Written detail for every category is below. How we measure content →
WHERE THE HARD PARTS ARE
  • “A Hero Is Unleashed” A bomb injures a police officer and his dog; surgery combines the dog's head with the officer's body.
  • Throughout the book Recurring jokes about urination and defecation.
  • Introduction to ‘Book ’Em, Dog Man’ A teacher's letter makes fun of a teacher's objection to comic-making in class and jokes about giving the student a behavior-modification drug.
  • “Weenie Wars: The Franks Awaken” A comic battle features an army of animated hot dogs being eaten.

A locator so a parent can pre-read the scenes that matter instead of the whole book.

Dominant Worldview and Other Worldview Content/Elements

Moral worldview celebrates loyalty, persistence and clever problem-solving, but repeated potty humor and jokes at a teacher's expense mar it.

Foul Language

The book uses potty words such as “pee” and “poop,” along with insults and dismissive remarks.

Violence

Light cartoon violence, such as a bomb explosion that leaves a police officer and dog needing life-saving surgery, slapstick accidents, criminal schemes and a hot-dog army being eaten. The opening injury is not shown realistically, and there is no realistic bloodshed.

Sex

No sex.

Nudity

No nudity.

Alcohol Use

No alcohol use.

Smoking and/or Drug Use and Abuse

No smoking or drug use. A teacher's note jokes about using a behavior-modification drug to curb a student's creativity.

Miscellaneous Immorality

Dog Man licks his boss, chews slippers and urinates indoors, and the book plays these dog behaviors for laughs. The book includes a mystery about defecation in the chief's office. Petey's schemes are villainous and are foiled. The police chief frequently yells at staff, and a teacher's letter introducing ‘Book ’Em, Dog Man’ mocks a teacher's objection to comic-making during class rather than encouraging respect for that authority.

Is the Writing Any Good?

Three stars: good, with real flaws. The colorful panels, Flip-O-Rama pages and energetic, childlike drawings give the book a distinctive comic rhythm. Pilkey makes the deliberately misspelled narration part of the joke, and his offbeat inventions keep the action moving. But the rough grammar and repeated toilet gags can wear thin, and the four adventures feel more like a string of escalating bits than a carefully shaped story.

Talk About It

Four questions for the dinner table, the car, or a parent and teen reading it together.

01

Dog Man keeps showing affection to the chief even when the chief is annoyed. How can you show kindness while still respecting someone's boundaries?

Ephesians 4:32 · Philippians 2:3–4
02

The book often treats bathroom jokes and insults as funny. What kinds of humor build people up, and what kinds can hurt or embarrass them?

Ephesians 4:29 · Proverbs 12:18
03

The school note makes a teacher's correction into a joke. How can you respond when an adult corrects you, and how can you tell whether a rule is there to help?

Ephesians 6:1–3 · Proverbs 12:1
04

Petey uses his cleverness to make trouble, while Dog Man uses it to stop him. How can you choose to use your own talents for good?

1 Peter 4:10 · Philippians 4:8

The Final Word

DOG MAN is a lively, inventive comic, but its frequent potty jokes, insults and teasing of a teacher are worth talking through. If your child is likely to repeat the crude humor, pass; if you welcome the silliness and can guide the conversation, share it together. Our answer: Read it together.

THE VERDICT Read it together.

More Books Like This

Browse All Reviews →