Skip to content
Give
← All Book Reviews
The Tryout, volume 1 Graphic novel
BOOK REVIEW

THE TRYOUT (AI DRAFT)

Cheerleading, friendship and belonging collide in a middle-school memoir.

Christina SoontornvatGraphix, an imprint of Scholastic272 pagesAges 8–12Graphic memoir
Read it together.
WRITING QUALITY ★★★★ 4 / 4 Expressive art, lively pacing and emotionally honest characters.
FAMILY CONTENT Discernment −1 on the +4 to −4 scale Discernment: discuss Buddhist worship presented alongside Christianity, and repeated racist bullying.
CONTENT LEVELS NONE → HEAVY
Language Light
Violence None
Sex None
Substances None
BEST FOR Middle-school readers who can discuss faith, friendship and prejudice with a parent.
NOT FOR Younger children reading alone, or families who do not want Buddhist practice shown alongside Christian worship.
IN ONE LINE A warm, well-crafted memoir with racist name-calling and an unresolved question about following Jesus and Buddha.
READING LEVEL Grades 5–8 · graphic format and conversational text; faith and bullying merit discussion.
WHERE TO GET IT Hardcover paperback ebook and unabridged audiobook Your library
SHARE f 𝕏 ✉ ⧉

The Worldview

Read it together. Christina’s courage, supportive family and loyalty to her friend make this an engaging memoir, but her questions about following Jesus and Buddha call for a parent’s guidance.

The book honors perseverance, family care and the repair of friendship after jealousy and hurtful choices. It also depicts racism plainly: classmates mock Christina’s food, misunderstand her Thai background and use a racist nickname. Those insults are shown as painful, not admirable. Her parents offer support, and Christina finds strength in her wider community.

Faith is part of the family’s life, but the book does not give a biblical answer to Christina’s spiritual questions. She attends a Presbyterian church and a Thai Buddhist temple, and wonders whether she can follow both Jesus and Buddha. That uncertainty deserves a clear, gentle conversation about what Christians believe and why other religions differ. Scripture calls Christians to welcome others without partiality, while also asking us to test spiritual claims. Christina’s longing to belong can open a conversation about the welcome Christ gives: “Therefore welcome one another as Christ has welcomed you, for the glory of God” (Romans 15:7).

Movieguide® worldview codes: B, C, FR, L, M — preserved for our database, awards research and the annual Report to the Entertainment Industry. What the codes mean →

The Story

NO SPOILERS — WE KEEP THE SURPRISES

Starting seventh grade without her best friend in any of her classes, Christina wants to fit in at her small Texas school. When she and Megan decide to try out for cheerleading, the months of practice bring excitement, pressure and new strain to their friendship. Christina also faces classmates’ assumptions about her Thai heritage and wrestles with what belonging means.

The Content Guide

The specifics — spoilers included by nature — so you can judge for your own reader.

Language Light
Violence None
Sex None
Substances None
The filled dot marks the level Movieguide® found in this book. For prose we report Substances in place of Nudity. Written detail for every category is below. How we measure content →
WHERE THE HARD PARTS ARE
  • Early school scenes A classmate mocks Christina’s Thai background and calls her “rice girl”; other racist jabs are mentioned.
  • Page 23, paperback A classmate insists Christina is Taiwanese after she says her father is from Thailand.
  • Page 78, paperback Christina’s mother recalls a waitress refusing to serve her and Christina’s father because they were a mixed-race couple.
  • Pages 142 and 148, paperback Christina attends Thai language lessons at a Buddhist temple and wonders whether someone can follow both Buddha and Jesus.
  • Baptism-and-salvation conversation The book presents differing claims about baptism and salvation alongside its comparison of Jesus and Buddha.

A locator so a parent can pre-read the scenes that matter instead of the whole book.

Dominant Worldview and Other Worldview Content/Elements

Moral worldview values courage, supportive family and friendship. Buddhist teaching and practice are presented positively alongside church attendance: Christina’s family prays at a Buddhist temple, and Jesus and Buddha are imagined as friends; the book also presents differing claims about baptism and salvation.

Foul Language

Light language: “turd” appears once. A bully repeatedly calls Christina “rice girl” and uses other racist jabs.

Violence

No violence.

Sex

No sex or romance.

Nudity

No nudity.

Alcohol Use

No alcohol use.

Smoking and/or Drug Use and Abuse

No smoking or drugs.

Miscellaneous Immorality

A classmate bullies Christina with racist taunts, and students and teachers sometimes fail to address exclusion. The story shows the hurt this causes rather than praising it. Christina sometimes puts others down to fit in and later regrets her hurtful words; jealousy and competition also strain her friendship with Megan.

Is the Writing Any Good?

Four stars: the memoir pairs lively, emotionally expressive artwork with a perceptive middle-school voice. Joanna Cacao’s colorful panels make Christina’s embarrassment, daydreams and growing confidence easy to read. The cheerleading plot gives the story momentum, while friendship and family keep it grounded. Some fantasy daydreams interrupt the real-life action, but the humor and honest account of awkward choices carry the story.

Talk About It

Four questions for the dinner table, the car, or a parent and teen reading it together.

01

Christina wonders whether she can follow both Buddha and Jesus. What would you want to ask or learn before deciding what to believe?

1 John 4:1 · James 1:5
02

When Christina is called a racist name, what could a classmate or teacher do to help? What would make it easier or harder to speak up?

James 2:1 · Proverbs 31:8–9
03

How does wanting the same opportunity strain Christina and Megan’s friendship? What helps friends handle competition without putting each other down?

Philippians 2:3–4 · Proverbs 17:17
04

Christina receives support from her family and community. Who helps you feel known and welcome, and how can you offer that welcome to someone else?

Romans 15:7 · Ephesians 4:32

The Final Word

THE TRYOUT is a funny, thoughtful memoir with strong artwork, loving family support and a serious look at racist bullying. Its portrayal of Buddhist practice alongside Christian worship, without a clear biblical distinction, is best discussed together. Read it together.

THE VERDICT Read it together.
Looking for something gentler for a younger reader? See our family-friendly book picks →

More Books Like This

Browse All Reviews →

Family-Friendly Alternatives