SUPERGIRL

The short answer: yes, especially if your family already loves superhero stories. The SUPERGIRL pilot is, in Movieguide's judgment, four-star television — brisk, witty, warm, and built around a heroine worth rooting for. Melissa Benoist carries the show with charm, the effects hold up well for broadcast TV, and there's a strong family thread running underneath the action that promises more emotional payoff as the series continues.

The caution is real but modest. There's action violence — Supergirl gets shot at, stabbed, kicked, punched, and strangled across several fight scenes — along with some light profanity. None of it is extreme, but it's enough that younger children should sit this one out.

The bigger thing to watch for isn't content, it's worldview: the show leans on "being true to yourself" as its guiding value, rather than pointing toward something greater than the self. It's a good-vs-evil story with a genuinely good heart — just don't expect the clearer biblical resonance of a MAN OF STEEL. Bottom line: worth watching, with older kids and up.

Kara Zor-El, Superman's cousin, was meant to arrive on Earth soon after him — but a detour through the Phantom Zone leaves her stranded for 24 years. When she finally lands, Superman places her with a human family who raised him through his own early discoveries. Now grown, Kara works a quiet office job in National City, powers hidden, purpose unclaimed — until an emergency forces her to decide whether to finally become who she was sent here to be.

Four stars means this pilot earns real enthusiasm, and the source material backs it up. The episode moves briskly from start to finish without dragging, the cast is likable and witty — Melissa Benoist especially so as the title character — and the special effects impress well beyond typical broadcast-TV standards. There's also a strong family component built into the show's foundation, one that promises to deliver more emotional weight as episodes accumulate. For a pilot, that's a lot to get right, and SUPERGIRL gets it right.

There's a lot to like here. Overtly Christian content is minimal, but the show's central engine — good confronting evil — echoes a truth Scripture takes seriously: that light and darkness are real, and that courage in defense of the innocent matters. Supergirl herself is offered as a role model, and the pilot backs that up with a genuine, unironic push toward being good and standing against evil.

The soft spot is what the show puts in place of a higher standard. Rather than pointing its heroine toward goals, virtues, or morals greater than herself, the pilot's guiding philosophy is "being true to yourself" — a Romantic ideal that flatters the self rather than calling it upward. There are light feminist undertones as well, though they sit at the edges rather than driving the story. None of this cancels the show's moral seriousness, but it does mean SUPERGIRL displays a less prominently Christian, biblical worldview than either MAN OF STEEL or SUPERMAN RETURNS.

That gap points to something worth naming out loud: the ache to discover your purpose and use your gifts for others is a good ache, but it finds its real answer not in looking inward but in looking up. "For we are his workmanship, created in Christ Jesus for good works, which God prepared beforehand, that we should walk in them" (Ephesians 2:10).

SUPERGIRL's pilot is a genuinely fun, well-crafted hour with a heroine worth cheering for and a family story worth watching unfold. It stumbles a little on worldview — leaning on self-discovery where it could point higher — and it earns its caution for younger viewers through some rough-and-tumble violence. Same answer we opened with: worth watching — older children and up.