ALI
Punch-drunk filmmaking makes this boxing biography a home-only choice.
Should You Watch It?
The source review finds ALI a serious disappointment. It covers Cassius Clay’s rise, his conversion to Islam and name change, his refusal to be drafted, his relationships, his journey to Africa, and his fight with George Foreman. But the film is described as tedious, boring, poorly edited, and unable to bring its subject’s real charisma to the screen.
The content is also unsuitable for families. The film includes foul language, boxing and other violence, sexual immorality, drinking, smoking, and a confused mixture of Muslim, humanist, anti-Christian, anti-Jewish, pro-black-power, and other ideas.
If you are an adult who remains interested, wait to watch it at home, where you can control the experience; do not choose it for children or young teens.
The Story
NO SPOILERS — WE KEEP THE SURPRISESALI follows Cassius Clay from his youth in Louisville through his boxing career, his friendship with sportscaster Howard Cosell, his conversion to Islam and name change, his refusal to be drafted, and his travels in Africa. The story also includes his marriages, controversies, and professional conflicts as he pursues another major fight.
Is It Any Good?
One star means the source review finds very little to recommend. ALI is called tedious, boring, and poorly edited, with a story that “goes nowhere and doesn’t know when it gets there.” Important events are presented through stereotypical moments, weakening the characters’ motivations.
Will Smith is considered okay in the title role but lacks the real Ali’s charisma. Jon Voight captures Howard Cosell’s mannerisms but is too low-key, while Mykelti Williamson is memorable as Don King. A few other actors provide superb vignettes, but the overall film is judged to have little to do with either history or filmmaking.
The Worldview
The film presents much Muslim content alongside some anti-Muslim content, humanist ideas, anti-Christian and anti-Jewish comments, pro-black-power and anti-black-power comments, and some pro-Christian comments. The source review says this mixture is confused, eclectic, pointless, and tied together only by superficial, stereotypical moments.
The review particularly objects to the film’s treatment of Christianity, including Ali’s complaint about the “blue-eyed Jesus.” It also says Islam is promoted throughout but ultimately comes across badly, while the film gives positive portraits of Mobutu and Idi Amin without addressing the tragic suffering they inflicted on their countries. The result, according to the source, is a distorted portrait of Ali and a mishmash of worldviews and political beliefs.
The film’s search for identity and meaning is ultimately left confused. Scripture calls believers to a different kind of transformation: “Do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewal of your mind” (Romans 12:2).
The Content Guide
The specifics — spoilers included by nature — so you can judge for your own family.
Content Summary
Confused, eclectic, pointless worldview with much Muslim content, some anti-Muslim contents, much humanist content, some anti-Christian & anti-Jewish comments, some pro-Christian comments, some pro-black power comments, some anti-black power comments; 22 obscenities, 4 profanities & 1 pointed blasphemy; lots of boxing violence with the now-overused ROCKY effects of slow-motion punches combined with appropriate sound effects, some non-boxing violence including man slaps around his friend, Malcolm X gets shot several times at point-blank range, & rioting on the streets & rioting on TV, with cars burning & people beaten up; several scenes of fornication but no female nudity shown, serial marriages & adultery with Ali admitting that his weakness as a Muslim is his attraction to women; men in boxing trunks, but no real salacious nudity; drinking sometimes to get drunk; smoking; and, much discussion of Islam, much ridicule of other people, positive portraits of Mobutu & Idi Amin, the man who literally cannibalized the people of Uganda in Africa, & unnecessary scene of Muhammed Ali going into cockpit of airline.
Talk About It
Questions for the drive home, the dinner table, or the youth group.
The film presents a confused search for identity through fame, religion, politics, and personal relationships. Where should a person ultimately ground his identity?
Colossians 3:1–4 · Galatians 2:20The source review says the film ridicules Christianity. How should Christians respond when their faith is mocked or misrepresented?
1 Peter 3:15–16 · Matthew 5:44The film includes adultery and serial marriages. What does Scripture teach about faithfulness and the covenant of marriage?
Matthew 19:4–6 · Hebrews 13:4The film presents violence, including boxing and public rioting. How does biblical wisdom distinguish courage from a love of violence?
Proverbs 16:32 · James 1:19–20The Final Word
ALI has an important subject but, according to the source review, turns it into tedious, poorly edited filmmaking with troubling content and a confused worldview. For discerning adults who remain interested, WAIT FOR HOME — ADULTS ONLY. For a better family movie night, try.