AMERICA: IMAGINE THE WORLD WITHOUT HER
An engaging, uplifting defense of America’s history and liberty.
Should You Watch It?
If you want an engaging documentary that defends America’s heritage and founding values, this is worth your time. Dinesh D’Souza addresses several indictments against America, including accusations involving Native Americans, slavery, Mexico, imperialism, and capitalism. The film argues that changing how Americans view their history can weaken their commitment to liberty and self-government.
The first two thirds are powerful, uplifting, and informative. The documentary also highlights people who overcame abuse and hardship, while emphasizing Christianity, ingenuity, entrepreneurship, and moral responsibility. Its weakness is that the final third shifts into a less connected summary of current politics. The film also could give greater credit to the Bible as the source of the values it celebrates.
Younger children may be troubled by the brief language and violence. For older children and adults, this is a worthwhile and inspiring documentary.
The Story
NO SPOILERS — WE KEEP THE SURPRISESThis documentary examines how America’s history is being reshaped and presented in ways that can make citizens ashamed of their heritage. D’Souza addresses several accusations against the country and argues that the facts reveal a more complicated history.
The film also considers how America’s founding values relate to liberty, Christianity, self-government, ingenuity, entrepreneurship, and prosperity. It closes by connecting the country’s history to current political struggles over freedom and the size of government.
Is It Any Good?
Four stars means this is a highly engaging and important documentary. The stories are powerful, uplifting, and informative, and D’Souza does a commendable job focusing on heroes who overcame abuse and succeeded against the odds.
The first two thirds are especially strong as the film discusses America’s history and the accusations directed against it. The final third is less well connected because it turns toward a summary of the current political situation. Some reenactments are also more engaging and inspiring than others. Even with those limitations, the documentary remains effective and worthwhile.
The Worldview
The documentary presents a strongly biblical, moral, Christian, and patriotic worldview. It emphasizes God, the Gospel, Christianity, moral living, liberty, ingenuity, entrepreneurship, and a business ethic supporting limited government and opposing statist tyranny. It also argues that America’s solutions to historical injustices were unique in their emphasis on Christianity, ingenuity, and entrepreneurship.
The film’s central argument is that Americans should know their history without excusing wrongdoing. It celebrates what the past allows people to become and urges viewers not to repeat the failures of fallen societies. It also presents the transfer of self-government to the federal government as a loss of moral responsibility, ingenuity, and prosperity.
The review’s chief worldview concern is that the documentary does not stress enough that the founders’ values were originally and inherently inspired by the Bible. By describing moral living, free-market principles, and liberty as uniquely American, the film does not give God all the credit and glory due, though it does mention Christianity’s importance in America.
The documentary’s longing for liberty and moral responsibility aligns with Scripture’s call to stand in freedom: “For freedom Christ has set us free” (Galatians 5:1).
The Content Guide
The specifics — spoilers included by nature — so you can judge for your own family.
Content Summary
Very strong biblical, moral worldview, with strong Christian elements, includes many references to God and the Gospel, and how it transforms lives and increases prosperity, a scene during a church service, and very strong patriotic, capitalist content/values promoting ingenuity, entrepreneurship and a moral business ethic supporting limited government and opposing statist tyranny, including a strong refutation of leftist revisionist history; three light obscenities, one bleeped GD by Saul Alinsky, the Rev. Jereremiah’s famous GD America line is repeated, and one bleeped “f” word; strong violence includes some action violence during the war reenactments, men are shot and some blood is seen, fight scenes from Matt Damon’s BOURNE series are shown, reference to brutal genocide and slavery, but nothing very graphic or more graphic than might be seen on some lighter History Channel documentaries; no sexual content, but man mentions “Calpones whore house”; a 1970’s “hippie” dances in a bikini, brief upper male nudity; no alcohol; smoking of cigarettes; and, no endorsement of immorality or Non-Christian, immoral worldviews or philosophies.
Talk About It
Questions for the drive home, the dinner table, or the youth group.
The film argues that knowing history matters for the future. Why should Christians remember both the good and evil in a nation’s past?
Psalm 78:4–7 · Romans 15:4The documentary praises liberty and self-government. How should Christian freedom shape the way we use responsibility and authority?
Galatians 5:1, 13 · 1 Peter 2:16The film highlights people who overcame abuse and hardship. Where do courage and perseverance come from when circumstances seem unjust?
James 1:2–4 · Romans 5:3–5The review says America’s values should receive more explicit credit as gifts rooted in the Bible. How should gratitude to God change the way we think about our nation’s achievements?
Deuteronomy 8:17–18 · James 1:17The Final Word
This is an engaging, inspiring, and informative documentary with a strongly biblical and patriotic message. Its final third is less connected, and younger viewers may not be ready for the brief language and violence. For older children and adults, our answer is WORTH THE TRIP — OLDER CHILDREN AND ADULTS.