MAY DECEMBER
Brilliantly made, morally rotten — and not worth your conscience.
Should You Watch It?
Let's be honest about both halves of this. Todd Haynes has directed a genuinely superb film — a slow-burning psychological drama with a fascinating script and three award-worthy performances, including a potentially star-making turn from Charles Melton. On craft alone, it earns every one of its four stars.
But craft is not the whole question, and here it isn't even the main one. The story is despicable by design. Its central marriage began when a 36-year-old wife and mother seduced a 12-year-old boy, and the film spends nearly two hours inside the manipulation, duplicity, and warped sexuality that followed. Add graphic adulterous sex, male nudity, strong profanity that takes the Lord's name in vain, and a scene of a father and teenage son smoking marijuana together.
A well-made film can still be one you shouldn't watch, and this is that film. Our answer is simple: skip it.
The Story
NO SPOILERS — WE KEEP THE SURPRISESGracie and Joe have been married nearly twenty years — but their marriage began in scandal, when Gracie, an older wife and mother, drew Joe into a relationship while he was still a boy.
Now a TV-star actress named Elizabeth arrives in their small town. She's been cast to play Gracie in a movie about the couple's notorious past, and as a Method actor she wants to live their world from the inside. She's charming on the surface. Underneath, something colder is at work — and once she gets close to this fragile family, the tensions begin to build.
Is It Any Good?
Four stars, and they're deserved on the merits. The script by Samy Burch is a fascinating, slow-burning psychological ride that at times feels like an homage to Hitchcock's Strangers on a Train. Todd Haynes directs with emotional brilliance, and the film builds to a great final twist in which the actress's own scheming turns against her.
The performances are the standout. All three leads have award potential, but Charles Melton's deeply layered portrait of Joe is the film's beating heart — showing a man emotionally frozen at twelve and quietly devastated by the marriage he never truly chose. It's the kind of turn that makes a career.
So the filmmaking is excellent. That excellence is precisely why the review says what it says next: skill spent on this material doesn't redeem it.
The Worldview
This is a film with a very strong pagan worldview, and it's worth naming plainly what that means here. Nearly every relationship in the story runs on manipulation, and warped sexuality is treated as simply the water everyone swims in. The actress, Elizabeth, is a sociopathic, narcissistic figure who doesn't care whether she destroys an already twisted marriage — so long as she gets the insight she needs for a great performance.
There is a thin thread of moral truth in it. The film does show the devastating mental and emotional toll the marriage has taken on Joe, and it correctly reveals that this marriage was built on great wrongs by Gracie. Elizabeth's intrusion is shown as insidious and, in the end, warped in the extreme. The movie sees the corruption clearly even as it wallows in it.
Haynes has often made films about illicit relationships, frequently with a homosexual element. There's no direct homosexuality here, though one long, tense scene of a woman applying makeup to another carries an unspoken lesbian charge. Weigh that as you consider the film's outlook.
Under all of it lies a story of appetite treated as license and people used as means. Scripture calls us the other direction entirely: "Let marriage be held in honor among all, and let the marriage bed be undefiled, for God will judge the sexually immoral and adulterous" (Hebrews 13:4).
The Content Guide
The specifics — spoilers included by nature — so you can judge for your own family.
Dominant Worldview and Other Worldview Content/Elements
Very strong pagan worldview about a sociopathic, narcissistic actress who doesn’t care if she destroys an already twisted marriage just to get the insights she needs to produce a great performance in a TV movie about the couple’s life, with lots of manipulation, sexual tensions, and duplicity, with some light moral elements where the movie shows the devastating mental and emotional consequences the twisted marital relationship has had on the husband, plus there’s an implied scene of lesbian lust between a married woman and an unmarried woman, but nothing is consummated
Foul Language
12 obscenities (including seven “f” words), four Jesus profanities, seven light profanities
Violence
No violence
Sex
extreme sexual content overall includes a graphic scene of depicted adulterous sex between a married man and an unmarried woman with the clothed woman’s legs spread apart, and the man on top of her, the man smiles very happily afterwards, a manipulative actress gives an erotically charged answer to a group of high school students who asked her what it’s like filming a sex scene, the movie’s plot centers around a now-married couple who started fornicating when the man was a 12-year-old boy and the woman was a 36-year-old wife of another man and mother of his family. here is a long scene with unspoken but seemingly lesbian sexual tension between two women as one applies makeup slowly and gently to the other’s lips and face, woman fantasizes about a sexual encounter between two other people (the fantasy is not shown, but it’s obvious by her panting and writhing that she’s pleasuring herself while engaging in these illicit sexual thoughts), woman nonchalantly starts reading a secret letter that a married man’s now-wife wrote to him when she was having a sexual relationship as a child, woman’s adult son tells another woman she started sex with her older brothers when she was 12
Nudity
A married man’s bare buttocks are seen as he engages in adulterous sex while atop a woman, and his shadowed genitals are clearly seen from above when he stands up
Alcohol Use
Casual drinking is seen in a couple of situations
Smoking and/or Drug Use and Abuse
Some smoking, and 17-year-old
Miscellaneous Immorality
Actress lies and manipulates her way into the home of a couple with a twisted marital relationship under the guise of doing research in order to perfectly play the wife in a TV movie about the couple, the actress obsessively studies the wife and engages in lots of intimate conversations with the husband and eventually seducing him into adulterous sex, the wife was a 36-year-old married mother when she began her relationship with her now-husband when he was just a 12-year-old boy, and 18 years later she still treats him like a child and manipulates him emotionally, the wife manipulates the actress mentally, the wife also manipulates her husband with childish crying fits to get what she wants.
Talk About It
Questions for the drive home, the dinner table, or the youth group.
The film shows how a relationship built on manipulation leaves lasting wounds on Joe. How does God intend love to treat another person — and how is that different from control?
1 Corinthians 13:4–7Gracie's marriage began with a grievous sin against a child, and eighteen years of "normal life" never made it right. What does Scripture say about wrongdoing that time cannot cover, and about the only thing that can?
Psalm 32:1–5 · 1 John 1:9Elizabeth uses charm as a mask for a cold, self-serving heart. Where do we tell ourselves that a good outcome justifies deceiving or using people?
Proverbs 12:22 · Romans 12:9This is a story where marriage is defiled and appetite runs the household. What does it look like to honor marriage and one another's bodies as holy instead?
Hebrews 13:4 · 1 Thessalonians 4:3–5The Final Word
May December is proof that a film can be made with real skill and still be one you should turn off. The performances are extraordinary; the story is corrupt to its foundation, and the sexual content alone puts it out of bounds. So our answer stands as we began: skip it. Looking for something worth your evening instead? Start with our family-friendly picks.