POPE FRANCIS: A MAN OF HIS WORD
A stirring portrait of compassion, marred by unbiblical ideas.
Should You Watch It?
This documentary offers stirring and touching moments as Pope Francis speaks with crowds and meets people facing poverty, disaster, illness, and displacement. Its strongest passages honor family life, the dignity of work, generosity, love, concern for children, and opposition to sin and abuse.
The film also presents a Roman Catholic viewpoint that sometimes departs sharply from Scripture. Pope Francis says Christians should “never proselytize,” and the documentary includes other politically correct, environmentalist, and unbiblical claims. Those ideas weaken an otherwise compassionate and often beautiful portrait.
If you can help older children weigh the film’s good moral themes against its errors, it is worth seeing. Watch it with discernment rather than accepting every statement as biblical truth.
The Story
NO SPOILERS — WE KEEP THE SURPRISESRather than telling Pope Francis’ life story, Wim Wenders takes a philosophical approach. The documentary follows Francis speaking to crowds at the Vatican, in South America, Philadelphia, and Africa, while intimate interview footage explores his views on faith, family, work, poverty, immigration, and the troubles facing humanity.
The film also shows the Pope visiting people affected by a hurricane, poverty, and refugee crises, giving the documentary a worldwide scope.
Is It Any Good?
Four stars means this documentary is stirring, affecting, and beautifully made. Wenders uses footage from around the Earth, along with magnificent music and carefully assembled montages of Pope Francis’ interactions with people worldwide.
The film becomes more nuanced and thought-provoking once its focus turns to Francis. Its images of the human spirit rising above hardship through faith in God are deeply moving. The intimate interview and public appearances give the documentary a personal, accessible quality.
Its weakness is not primarily its craft. The problem is that its philosophical and political claims sometimes become heavy-handed, superficial, or false.
The Worldview
The documentary presents a strong Christian and moral worldview from a Roman Catholic viewpoint. It emphasizes family life, the dignity of work, fair pay, a healthy balance between work and relaxation, love, compassion, avoiding temptation and sin, and the well-being of children. Pope Francis mentions Jesus Christ and God and makes several biblical references.
The film also highlights Francis’ concern for the poor, refugees, victims of natural disaster, and people suffering from violence. His opposition to the Catholic Church’s pedophilia crisis and his simpler lifestyle are presented as admirable examples.
However, these positive themes are marred by Romantic, unbiblical, politically correct, and environmentalist platitudes. The documentary includes disputed claims about pollution, climate change, poverty, wealth, and landfills. Pope Francis also says that Christians should “never proselytize,” directly contradicting Christ’s command to make disciples of all nations. His “Who am I to judge?” comment about practicing homosexuals is also presented without addressing God’s moral law.
The film longs for a world marked by love, justice, mercy, and human dignity. Scripture calls Christians to those virtues while also calling them to proclaim Christ: “Go therefore and make disciples of all nations” (Matthew 28:19).
The Content Guide
The specifics — spoilers included by nature — so you can judge for your own family.
Dominant Worldview and Other Worldview Content/Elements
Strong Christian, moral, biblical worldview from overall culled from an interview with the current head of the Roman Catholic Church, Pope Francis, who voices his ideas and beliefs on a number of social, spiritual, and political issues (including comments about the importance of family life, of paying workers enough money for them to live, promoting a proper balance of work and relaxation in our hectic modern world, and some comments about sin), with some mentions of Jesus Christ and God and some biblical references but no references to the Holy Spirit, mitigated by some strong Romantic, unbiblical and politically correct platitudes and comments from Pope Francis (including strong radical environmentalist elements and comments from the Pope and Narrator Wim Wenders), such as ugly shots of landfills that give a false impression about pollution and humanity harming the Earth plus a brief unbiblical comment by Pope Francis excusing perversion
Foul Language
No foul language
Violence
Movie depicts some of the consequences after and during natural and human violence such as suffering after the effects of a hurricane, footage of starving people in Nazi concentration camps, and images of the refugee crisis in Europe and Syria includes a boatload of people flips over and results in a panicked rescue of most, but there’s at least one implied death as a body is shown being carried in a body bag from a distance
Sex
No sex, but Pope takes an antinomian approach to homosexual behavior that’s pro-homosexual and unbiblical (he says that as long as a homosexual person believes in God and tries to live nicely, “Who am I to judge?”), yet Pope condemns pedophile abusers in the Catholic Church hierarchy
Nudity
No nudity
Alcohol Use
No alcohol
Smoking and/or Drug Use and Abuse
No smoking or drugs Smoking content and/or level of drug use or abuse;
Miscellaneous Immorality
Some meaningless platitudes, false, and misleading comments are made.
Talk About It
Questions for the drive home, the dinner table, or the youth group.
The film emphasizes the importance of family life and love. How can your family show love through ordinary acts of service?
1 Corinthians 13:4–7 · 1 John 3:18Pope Francis speaks about the dignity of work and paying workers enough to live. How does Scripture connect work, justice, and care for others?
Colossians 3:23–24 · James 5:4The documentary presents compassion for refugees, the poor, and people facing disaster. Who around you needs practical mercy this week?
Matthew 25:35–40 · Luke 10:30–37The film says Christians should never proselytize. What did Jesus actually command His followers to do?
Matthew 28:18–20 · Luke 24:47The Final Word
This is a beautifully made, compassionate documentary with genuine moral strengths. But its unbiblical claims require discernment, especially its rejection of evangelism and its treatment of sexual morality. For older children and adults prepared to discuss those errors, WORTH THE TRIP — OLDER CHILDREN AND ADULTS.