WHAT IS A WOMAN?
Lively, provocative, informative, and brilliant — for discerning adults.
Should You Watch It?
WHAT IS A WOMAN? is a forceful documentary built around questions that its subjects often struggle to answer. Matt Walsh interviews activists, medical professionals, academics, critics, athletes, and others about puberty blockers, sex-change surgery, pronouns, the differences between sex and gender, and body mutilation.
The source review praises the film as lively, provocative, informative, and brilliant. It especially values Walsh’s calm questioning, the critics’ contributions, and the documentary’s willingness to let opposing views speak before examining their claims. It also presents serious concerns about the treatment of children and the effects of gender-transition procedures.
The cost is substantial adult content, including 14 obscenities, two bleeped “f” words, brief nudity, and disturbing discussions of suicide, sexual abuse, and surgery. For discerning adults, this is WORTH THE TRIP — ADULTS ONLY.
The Story
NO SPOILERS — WE KEEP THE SURPRISESAuthor and radio host Matt Walsh begins with questions about the differences between boys and girls and the cultural messages children receive about gender identity.
He then travels from city streets to professional offices and interviews people on several sides of the debate, including therapists, surgeons, pediatricians, professors, psychologists, athletes, activists, and critics. His search for a clear definition of “woman” eventually takes him to Kenya, where he asks tribesmen how their community understands the differences between men and women.
Is It Any Good?
Four stars means this documentary succeeds exceptionally well on its own terms. The source review calls it lively, provocative, informative, and brilliant.
Its central craft strength is the interview method. Walsh calmly questions people with sharply different views, asks them to explain their beliefs, and presses both sides about their opponents’ arguments. The critics are described as terrific, and the documentary is praised for allowing its subjects to reveal weaknesses in their own positions rather than presenting only a one-sided argument.
The film is also described as formidable and intellectually forceful. Its tone is clearly combative, but the review finds Walsh’s concern for truth and what is right compelling.
The Worldview
WHAT IS A WOMAN? strongly affirms biological sex as real and binary. It questions the idea that people can define themselves as male or female apart from their bodies, and it condemns medical procedures that alter children’s bodies for psychological or political reasons. The documentary also argues that gender is vague and unmeasurable, while temperament and personality can vary between men and women.
The film exalts truth, clear definitions, intellectual honesty, protection of children, and traditional distinctions between male and female. It presents gender-identity politics as confused, irrational, politically coercive, and harmful to vulnerable children. It also connects these ideas to the history of Alfred Kinsey and John Money, whom the source review describes as having promoted sexual ideas and conducted horrific experiments involving children.
The documentary refers to Judeo-Christian values and aligns with the biblical affirmation that God created humanity as male and female. Its direct argument is cultural and political rather than a full biblical account of human dignity, sin, redemption, or pastoral care. Scripture says, “So God created man in his own image, in the image of God he created him; male and female he created them” (Genesis 1:27).
The Content Guide
The specifics — spoilers included by nature — so you can judge for your own family.
Dominant Worldview and Other Worldview Content/Elements
Very strong moral worldview where man frankly questions various “experts” and activists on transgender issues, including the use of “puberty blockers,” surgery, the use of new “gender” pronouns, the differences between sex and gender, and body mutilation, with a reference to “Judeo-Christian values” and many references to homosexual and transgender ideology
Foul Language
14 obscenities, no profanities and two bleeped “f” words
Violence
Some discussion of body mutilation of children, genital surgery of children, suicide, and getting/doing mastectomies for psychological and political reasons on teenagers, plus a man deliberately bumps into another man during a demonstration and other leftist protestors angrily denounce the victim in a threatening manner
Sex
Brief references to being homosexual, many references to being transgender, discussion of child sexual abuse by two perverted “scientists,” Alfred Kinsey and John Money at John Hopkins University who normalized homosexuality and gender identity/confusion
Nudity
Transgender man exposes his breasts, host interviews a totally naked man and there’s a partial flash of his upper genital area, other scenes with upper male nudity, and two or so brief images of female cleavage
Alcohol Use
No alcohol use
Smoking and/or Drug Use and Abuse
No smoking or drugs;
Miscellaneous Immorality
Some pro-abortion protestors harass and insult a journalist asking questions about the definition of a woman, a sex change surgeon says people who disagree with her gender identity beliefs are bigots and “dinosaurs,” a woman on the street says truth is relative and contends that what’s “true for you” is not necessarily true for her.
Talk About It
Questions for the drive home, the dinner table, or the youth group.
The film repeatedly asks what is true and whether truth can be relative. Why does truth matter when difficult questions affect children and families?
John 8:31–32 · Ephesians 4:25The documentary distinguishes biological sex from temperament and personality. How can we recognize real differences without treating anyone as less valuable?
Genesis 1:27 · James 2:1–4Several questions concern medical decisions made for children. What responsibilities do adults have when caring for vulnerable children?
Mark 9:36–37 · James 3:1Walsh questions people with views on both sides of the debate. What does it look like to pursue truth while listening carefully and speaking with humility?
Proverbs 18:13 · James 1:19The Final Word
WHAT IS A WOMAN? is an unusually energetic documentary that presses its questions clearly and lets its subjects’ answers receive scrutiny. Its adult content and disturbing subject matter make it unsuitable for children and young teens. For discerning adults, the answer is WORTH THE TRIP — ADULTS ONLY.